Posts made by Mr Depp

@admin What is the time we can expect for the solution ?

Hello team,

Recently major changes happen in the login api and we still don't have any update for the TOTP for the c#.net library.

Can you please let us know when you are going to update the code in c#.net library so we can use it. As we have seen that you already provided solution for the python and go lang and java.
but escaping the c#.net platform to providing the solution.

do you really think that c#.net is not a language ? Every time your updates are coming late for the c#.net. Do you have any valid reason to ignore this particular language ?

Hello team.

What about the c#.net sdk update ? did you updated to the library or setting some another way to use it ?

Hello Team,

We are facing issue of the error code "AB2000" while calling the api request for getPosition() using c#.net library.

We have holding of bank nifty futures in our customers account and now we are not receiving information regarding carryforward positions or even any position. Now tell us how we can make a automatic algorithm in the kind of system ? can any one tell me how my software will understand what to do and what trades are needed to be closed.

We were hoping for the good product but day by day all the routing running items are effected don't know why? We are even not solving the problems but every day we are generating the new specific problem in the system? Do you seriously have a testing team for the API or you just change the code and make directly live to the server. And even I m wondered about the error code description which is Error not specified.. Are you serious ?

It has problem with the carryforward data. I mean if there is no any intraday position is active on account i got the error if there is at least a single intraday position exist I got response from the same function. So check it out and try to solve it if you can.

Hello Team,

We have at least 10 to 15 point data variation at each and every candle of the nifty 50 index data which is displayed in the chart.

I use the link

https://trade.angelbroking.com/portfolio/chart/index

is it the valid link m I using ?

if it is yes than this is must be a disaster.

consider the data variation

True data
Date 6/16/2022 Hour 11 Minute 48
Trading Symbol Nifty 50 Candle Open 15606.4 Candle High 15606.4 Candle Low 15588.8 Candle Close 15588.8

Zerodha
Date 6/16/2022 Hour 11 Minute 48
Trading Symbol Nifty 50 Candle Open 15605.65 Candle High 15606.40 Candle Low 15589.70 Candle Close 15589.70

Angel
Date 6/16/2022 Hour 11 Minute 48
Trading Symbol Nifty 50 Candle Open 15619.45 Candle High 15625.25 Candle Low 15605.95 Candle Close 15606.80

Are you serious team? This doesn't make any sense. We are executing algorithm using angel smart api and trading in angle but unfortunately we forcefully need to verify every every data with zerodha. It Doesn't make a sense. if we want to compete those technical platforms than first of all we have to get rid of the bad impression in our existing users mind only because of the data validation and verification.

We are still looking far from those platforms and this is really annoying. We all angel user want to see our platform a very strong and having a sense of the data. can you please consider this thing on priority base because there are many drawback and bad impressions in users mind.

Lets make angel the better platform together but for this we need all support from your side. We are researching and find problems and can let you know where is the issue but it is now your responsibility to solve the problem.

Thanks.

Please find out here with attachment regarding the problem.

@Mnagesh you can keep 1 minute and 40 second delay after calling every historical candle if you are using angel historical data. you will get the near by perfect data. so set the crone job at after every 1 minute and 40 seconds.

@Mnagesh But there is no order id is available in the getposition.
i want to manage everything based on order id because i want to calculate how each orders are executed rather than displaying the sum of all order. for example if i buy reliance and at 1000 and again i buy another qty after some time in the same script reliance than system will show the average price but that is not my concern. i want to separate entry by the order id not the over all average price.

How can I check either the particular order was exit at profit or loss by using the orderid ?

thanks.

Hello team,

While trading in the future and option what does quantity mean in the holding response comes from the angel api. I mean is it display the quantity as a number of lot or the total qty.

for example if i buy bank nifty 1 lot 25 qty so what will be the output of the getholding method response ? is it 1 (that means number of lot ) or 25 (means the total qty )

Thanks.

Hello team,

I m calling getHolding() method and get the response as well.
Now I have confusion about the quantity in in the response. there are two kind of quantity are there first one is quantity and another one is t1quantity. What does it mean ?

so can any one please clear the term and difference between the quantity and t1 quantity and which quantity should I consider to exit the trade ?

Thanks.

Hello Team,
Is Index Future Data is available in Historical data api?

if yes than can you provide any sample example how to get those data?

Thanks.

Hello Team,

I have found a huge gap in the nifty index future rates.
about 699 rs gap from current rate to current day high. i have verified with the chard candle there is also a problem. i compared with other brokers their data is okay for today onwards 05-07-2021.

Please solve this kind of issues because it is really miss guiding people for trading matters.

Please find out here with attachment regarding the problem.

Thanks.

Hello team,

I found a huge data mistake in Acc stock here is request parameters

Trading token = 22
from date - 2020-11-23 09:15
To Date - 2020-11-23 15:30
Trading Symbol - ACC
Time Frame 1 hour

if you can check the low of stock is 206 rs while acc never traded at this price in specific time period.

Please find out here with attachment regarding problem

Please solved out this kind of issues as fast as possible because it miss leading all the people.

@ASR you can download your python library from git hub

https://github.com/angelbroking-github/smartapi-python

complete sample code is there. where you get all the things and code you want that how to get JWT Token and how your historical data will get in response.

@ASR Which language are you using for the code?

@admin A98281

@admin query is different so I Posted it differently but no problem sir i will share in one post.

Hello Team,

Here i m adding another problem about historical data response consistency.

Another new query in feeding data.

request parameter
Stock Acc
Trading token 22
Time interval 1 minute
from 02-01-2017 feb 2017
to 02 -28 - 2017 feb 2017

i call it first time and get response total number of candles are ok
but for the first time first candle is started from 9 : 16 and last candle 9 : 30
when i call it again with same parameter
i got first candle 9 : 15 and last candle 9 : 29

i think all time result must be same.

Please find out here with attachment regarding the problem.

This issue is not already explained this is another new issue I found.

@admin both queries are different sir.

1 query is providing irregular number of candles
and
2 query is not return even a single candle. the whole json is blank some times.

@Mr-Depp
Stock SBIN
Exchange nse
One hour time frame
from 01-01-2017
to 04-01-2017

all parameters are displayed in screen shot sir