Posts made by Mnagesh

@admin

Revised Charges:

Brokerage Equity - Delivery
Previous :Lower of INR 20 or 0.1%,
Minimum INR 2
Current : Lower of INR 20 or 0.1%,
Minimum INR 5

Brokerage Equity - Intraday
Previous : Lower of INR 20 or 0.03%
Current : Lower of INR 20 or 0.1%,
Minimum INR 5

Not Happy:
we camnot paticipate in smallcase - if the smallcase has 12 script then we need to pay 5 x 12 = 60 for brokerage min

or

If the script ltp is 100rs the we cannot buy 1 share ...the cost will be 5 brokerage ...that is 5 % we lost by investing .
it works only if we buy 50 shares of 100 ltp then only it will be otimal
we cannot diversify our investment with littel money investemt - too coustly for samll capital investors

Angel one should comapre their brokerage with the peers and justify .

@admin VEDL

i am unable to upload image here - which would have given better clarity

anyhow you can check the greeks with angel one vs sensibull by yourself and understand that the greeks provided by angel is wrong ones !!!

@admin
no reply from admin

@admin
I suspect the option Greeks provided by angel one is accurate and correct value ?

I checked with sensibull and angel - they both differ and difference is huge .

some one should let us know which one is accurate .

if i use smatrapi to get option Greeks... it may be erroneous as per sensibull and opastra

is there any way we can check the accurecy of angel one ?

i am observing the option greeks provided by Angel One is not matching with the sensibul and it is not matching with the opstra too.

sensibul and opstra are providing correct values it seems and they both are in sync and matching.

The Option Greeks values provided by angelone in mobile app is totally different and i suspect the values are correct or not !!!

kindly some one should verify those values .

we cannot implement/relied depending on angel one greeks values, especially implementing algos depending on suspected values .

@dipankar

1. get Json data
2. convert it into dataframe
3. apply filter

@admin did you checked? greeks are not accurate .
so we cannot depend on greeks provided by smartapi .

@s2108014

create an app with user log in.

Single program you cannot have multiple logins .

you need to create a different individual thread for each individual client.

@admin
not checked with smartapi values yet

I am not sure the Angel app gives the accurate Greeks values .

I checked with sensibull and Angelone - it seems sensibull is giving the accurate values .

today i took screen sort of both of them around 3:02 foe VEDL 25 NOV 2025 CE 550 strike option and found the value we found in sensibull is differ from Angelone mobile app .

I lost all my charts study templates.

There is no proper response from angel one .

this might have been happen due to recent mobile app update from play store .

wish you good luck in all your trading .

Is any one is doing arbitrage Future and Equity pair NFO?

the ltp for ICICIGI OCT FUT is not update
ltp is showing 2005
where as buy sell tx are happing at 1960 around

@oaktree_priyanka

add fund one has to use either app or trade angel web only.

similarly withdraw also through app or web but not api

@Mitrajit use underlying instrument
like nifty index instead of nifty future or options
similarly use SBIN-EQ instead of SBIN future or options

@mst_rajatmishra

1. Without pycryto smartapi will work
2. install one by one rather then using requirement in one go.
3. better to use python 3.10.13 otherwise TA-LIB will not be installed

Getting totp error for one of my client .

[I 240608 11:04:15 smartConnect:121] in pool
[E 240608 11:04:15 smartConnect:243] Error occurred while making a POST request to https://apiconnect.angelbroking.com/rest/auth/angelbroking/user/v1/loginByPassword. Error: Invalid totp. URL: https://apiconnect.angelbroking.com/rest/auth/angelbroking/user/v1/loginByPassword, Headers: {'Content-type': 'application/json', 'X-ClientLocalIP': '127.0.0.1', 'X-ClientPublicIP': '106.193.147.98', 'X-MACAddress': '64:00:6a:07:e2:96', 'Accept': 'application/json', 'X-PrivateKey': 'VhEczsBX', 'X-UserType': 'USER', 'X-SourceID': 'WEB'}, Request: {'clientcode': 'xxxxxxx', 'password': 'xxxx', 'totp': 'xxxxxx'}, Response: {'status': False, 'message': 'Invalid totp', 'errorcode': 'AB1050', 'data': None}

@Moderator_1
@Moderator_2
@Moderator_3

I am using Marker Data Api

{ "mode": "LTP", "exchangeTokens": { "NSE":  ["3045","881"] ]} }

May i know the number of tokens we can use to fetch the data.

In the above example there are only two tokens

I tried for 100 tokens - It gives limit exceeds error

for list of 50 tokens it is working fine .

@Moderator_1
@Moderator_2
@Moderator_3

@anand02nikhil we can write our own function for that !